Paper: Storytelling, The Next Step for Visualization

Visualization is often considered to consist of three phases: exploration, analysis, and presentation. While the former two topics are covered well in the literature, there has been very little work specifically on presentation. In an upcoming paper, Jock Mackinlay and I argue that presentation, and in particular storytelling and communication of data, are the logical next step for the field, and provide some research directions.

The paper is titled Storytelling: The Next Step for Visualization and was written for IEEE Computer, in particular the Special Issue on Cutting-Edge Research in Visualization, to be published in May. This is important context to understand what we were trying to achieve and why the paper’s style is a bit unusual.

That entire special issue is likely to be very interesting. The guest editors, Min Chen and Theresa-Marie Rhyne, asked people in the field to write about what they envision visualization research to do 5, 10, or even 15 years in the future. While I don’t know what other papers will be in the issue, I’ve heard rumors that there were some high-profile submissions. And the topic clearly lends itself to some interesting thought experiments.

Our paper first explores the history of presentation and  storytelling with visualization, though there really isn’t much there. Only a handful of papers can really count as presentation, so we had to reach back a bit and include some historical perspective that goes beyond the visualization literature. We then talk about our particular idea of how we think storytelling should be approached, which is strongly influenced by journalism. It is not limited to the typical passive consumer though, so we outline some scenarios in which presentation and storytelling could be used. We illustrate these points with three case studies: Minard, Gapminder, and a story from the New York Times. The final section then provides some ideas about further steps and research directions.

If the formatting looks a bit odd, it is because this is a pre-print, which is still going through its editing phase. IEEE now makes these available very early though, in their rough form. While some of the text is likely going to change (since Computer has a particular style), the meat of the paper will not. Also, the goal of this paper was not a technical contribution or particular depth, but to lay out the general idea and discuss research directions. I hope to have some more in-depth work published later this year.

In related news, I was on a panel on storytelling with Alberto Cairo last week at the Computation and Journalism Symposium. Alberto has posted the slides he used during his opening remarks, with a bit of narration of his thoughts and some questions to go with them. I won’t post my slides or thoughts here for the moment, since I talked about some things that are about to become part of a paper submission, but I will say this: there is plenty of interesting work to be done with regards to presentation, communication. explanation, and storytelling with data.


Robert Kosara, Jock Mackinlay, Storytelling: The Next Step for VisualizationComputer (Special Issue on Cutting-Edge Research in Visualization), May 2013. (to appear)

Comments

  1. Helwig Hauser says

    Nice contribution to Computer, congratulations! :-) I see that you also address this interesting question of how to integrate interaction in storytelling. In [1], we related this question to the “narrative paradox” (according to Aylett, 1999) and discussed (1) passive story consumption, (2) story playback with interactive approval, (3) semi-interactive story playback, and (4) total separation from the story in the terms of how the story decouples from its original line during telling. Maybe that’s something you find interestingly fitting to your ideas about how to make storytelling interactive?
    [1] Michael Wohlfart and Helwig Hauser: Story Telling for Presentation in Volume Visualization. Proceedings of the 9th Joint EUROGRAPHICS – IEEE vgtc Symposium on Visualization (EuroVis 2007), May 23-25, 2007, in Norrköping, Sweden, pp. 91-98.

Leave a Reply